Approval of plans for the development and operation of petroleum fields declared invalid due to procedural errors

Supreme Court judgment and order of 13 November 2026, HR-2026-2428-S (case no. 26-005381SIV-HRET) and (case no. 26-007995SIV-HRET), civil case, appeal against Borgarting Court of Appeal's judgment and order of 14 November 2025.

I. The State, represented by the Ministry of Energy (The Office of the Attorney General, acting through Advocate Fredrik Sejersted) (assisted by Advocate Gøran Østerman Thengs) v. Föreningen Greenpeace Norden, Natur og Ungdom (Advocate Jenny Arge Sandvig), and Redd Barna (intervener) (Advocate Emanuel Feinberg)

II. The State, represented by the Ministry of Energy (The Office of the Attorney General, acting through Advocate Fredrik Sejersted) (assisted by Advocate Gøran Østerman Thengs) v. Föreningen Greenpeace Norden and Natur og Ungdom (Advocate Jenny Arge Sandvig)

The case concerns the validity of decisions approving Plans for Development and Operation (PDOs) for the Breidablikk and Tyrving petroleum fields and the Yggdrasil area, which consists of three fields. All are located in the North Sea. The case raises questions concerning the requirements applicable to environmental impact assessments of the climate effects of combustion emissions from produced oil and gas.

“Combustion emissions” refers to greenhouse gas emissions that occur when the oil and gas extracted from the petroleum fields are burned after being sold. Greenhouse gas emissions from the development and production activities themselves are referred to as “production emissions”.

Prior to the decisions approving the PDOs for the fields in question, environmental impact assessments were prepared. Emissions to air were assessed, but the assessments covered only production emissions and not combustion emissions. The environmental organisations Föreningen Greenpeace Norden and Natur og Ungdom brought an action seeking declarations that the decisions were invalid due to procedural errors. They contended that the environmental impact assessments should also have included combustion emissions.

The Supreme Court sitting as a grand chamber unanimously held that, under the EU Environmental Impact Assessment Directive, as implemented in Norwegian law, the combustion emissions resulting from petroleum extraction must be assessed before a PDO can be approved. This is consistent with the advisory opinion delivered by the EFTA Court in the case. The assessment must also describe and evaluate the anticipated climate impact of those emissions, measured by their effect on global warming.

The Supreme Court also addressed the extent to which combustion emissions must be assessed. This question was not referred to the EFTA Court and is not discussed in its advisory opinion.

On this issue, the Supreme Court, by a six-to-five majority, held that the Directive requires the environmental impact assessment to include both the combustion emissions from the project in question and the aggregate emissions from other existing and approved projects on the Norwegian continental shelf. In other words, the combustion emissions from the project at issue must be considered in light of the fact that the Norwegian authorities have already authorised a large number of other petroleum extraction projects that generate emissions.

The Supreme Court further held unanimously that the Directive does not require the environmental impact assessment to address the specific consequences of the increase in temperature that may result from the combustion emissions.

There was also unanimity that the authorities must assess whether the proposed activity is compatible with national and international obligations to take effective measures to prevent the harmful effects of climate change. However, this does not entail a requirement that the emissions in question be assessed against remaining carbon budgets, as argued by the environmental organisations.

The same majority of six justices held that the environmental impact assessments and the authorities’ evaluations were deficient. While the subsequent decisions not to revoke the approvals included assessments of combustion emissions, they failed to take into account the aggregate emissions from existing and approved petroleum extraction projects on the Norwegian continental shelf. The approvals were therefore declared invalid due to procedural errors.

The minority, on the other hand, held that there was no requirement to consider the emissions from the projects in question in conjunction with emissions from other projects on the Norwegian continental shelf approved by the Norwegian authorities and therefore concluded that the subsequent decisions had remedied the deficiencies in the original approvals.

The licence holders, that is, the oil companies, were not parties to the case before the Supreme Court. Consequently, the fact that the approvals were declared invalid due to procedural errors in proceedings between the environmental organisations and the State did not mean that the licences automatically ceased to have effect vis-à-vis the licence holders. The Ministry nevertheless had to reconsider the matter on the basis of proper procedure.

The judgment clarifies the requirements applicable to environmental impact assessments of greenhouse gas emissions in connection with the approval of plans for the development and operation of petroleum deposits.

A full-text translation of the Supreme Court's decision will be provided. 

Areas of law: Administrative law, environmental law, petroleum law, EEA law, civil procedure.

Key paragraphs: 92, 151, 178, 191, 213, 222, 225-228, 238-239, 243.

Justices: Øie, Webster, Falkanger, Falch, Østensen Berglund, Høgetveit Berg, Steinsvik, Sivertsen, Poulsen, Vang and Horn.