Question of punishment for elaborating on a false statement

Supreme Court judgment of 19 November 2026, HR-2026-2500-A (case no. 26-110769STR-HRET), criminal case, appeal against Gulating Court of Appeal's judgment of 28 May 2026.

A (Advocate Rune Håkon Tjomsland) v. The Public Prosecution Authority (Acting Public Prosecutor Sverre-Mangor Innjord)

A man had on several occasions told the police that he had been the victim of a racially motivated assault, whereas his injuries had in fact been caused by an e-scooter accident. The issue was whether he could be punished for his final false statement, in which he elaborated on and supplemented his earlier account.

The Supreme Court noted that a person who repeats a false statement can, as a general rule, be punished only for the initial statement. This is because no one should be compelled to reveal his own criminal conduct. The position may, however, be different where the person does not merely repeat the earlier falsehoods but elaborates on and supplements them.

The Supreme Court agreed with the Court of Appeal's interpretation of the law. A subsequent false statement may be punishable if it contains new inaccurate information that is not necessary to protect the person giving the statement from criminal liability. Whether the information was necessary must be assessed on the basis of how the accused himself perceived the situation at the time he gave the statement.

The Supreme Court further held that this interpretation did not expand criminal liability, but merely clarified the content of the rule. Accordingly, the interpretation was not contrary to the requirement that criminal punishment must have a clear legal basis.

However, the Court of Appeal had not described with sufficient clarity how the new information had emerged, including which questions the police had asked. The Supreme Court was therefore unable to determine whether the elaborations and supplementary statements had been necessary to protect the man from criminal liability. The judgment of the Court of Appeal was therefore set aside.

Area of law: Criminal law. False statement. The requirement of a legal basis. Section 221 of the Penal Code. 

Key paragraphs: 25–27

Justices: Falkanger, Hellerslia, Stenvik, Horn, Wennerås